When the first swing started in the first hour and is still going after 2 hours (bar 24), how often does the day become a trend day the other way, and what does the first swing do next?
Step 1 · The question
The question: my blog post "First Swing is Down: Is the Bull Trend Day Gone?" (zentradingtech.com) says: "If the first swing started in the first hour and is still running at bar 24, the trend day the other way is off the table. 2 days in nearly 11 years." Is that true at bar 24 itself, which bar is the right check point, and what does the first swing do next? This study tests a reading, not a trade setup.
Short answer: Low, not zero. At bar 24, 13 of 1,251 ES days (1.0%) became a trend day the other way. The "2 days" came from a rule that needs the rest of the day. No trend day the other way came when swing 1 had already run 70% ADR or more by bar 24.
Baseline · days with a first swing
3.2%
ES trend day the other way
First swing longer than 2 hours
1.0%
low 13 of 1,251 days
Change
-2.1
percentage points, from unrounded values
Times the baseline
0.33
relative change
How often
45.4%
of all ES days · about 114 a year
Key findings
A trend day the other way is low once swing 1 is longer than 2 hours. ES 1.0% and FDAX 1.5% of those days, about a third (ES) and a half (FDAX) of the share on all days with a first swing. Step 3
No single bar is the check point. On ES the share falls smoothly from bar 6 to bar 36; FDAX bear swings stay near their baseline until bar 21. Step 3
Swing 1's size by bar 24 sorts the days the other way. Every one of them had swing 1 under 70% ADR at bar 24. At 70% ADR or more: 424 ES days and 187 FDAX days, none the other way. Step 4
The trend day swing 1's way rises the longer swing 1 runs. ES bull: 28% at bar 12, 36% at bar 24, 48% at bar 48, against 27% on all bull first swings. It stays low probability (ES bull 36% at bar 24). Trading Range stays the most likely day until bar 39 to 42 on ES bull swings, and to bar 48 on the rest. Step 5
Every day the other way is an opening reversal. On my Swing Day Type all 13 ES and 10 FDAX days are ORRVD or ORV days: swing 1 was later undone. None is a trend from the open the other way. Step 8
After bar 24 price goes about as far one way as the other. ES bull middle day: 27% ADR on, 22% ADR back. Step 6
Swing 1 often runs to the close. On 43% of ES bull and 18% of ES bear days with a first swing longer than 2 hours its 40% ADR pullback never comes. Step 7
Terms
ADR: the average of the last 8 daily ranges, known before the open.
RTH: the regular day session. Xetra: the German day session for FDAX. Tick: the smallest price step.
Bar N: the Nth 5-minute bar of the session; bar 24 closes 2 hours after the open.
Leg: a move of at least 15% ADR. Swing: a move of at least 40% ADR built from legs, ended by a 40% ADR pullback. Leg walk: the rule that marks legs and swings bar by bar from the open; run on bars 1 to N it shows what was known at bar N.
Swing 1: the day's first swing. Its start bar is where it starts; its high or low is its furthest point.
First swing longer than 2 hours (the live rule): swing 1 started in the first hour (by bar 12) and has not ended at the 2-hour mark (the bar 24 close). At another check bar the same rule reads "not ended by that bar". The leg walk checks it: at the close of the check bar, the leg walk on bars 1 to that bar has swing 1 in, started by bar 12, with no 40% ADR pullback yet.
Whole-day rule: swing 1 starts by bar 12 and its high or low comes after bar 24, worked out on the whole day. The rule in the post; a reference row only.
Confirmed: the bar swing 1 first reaches 40% ADR from its start. Ended: the first bar price is 40% ADR back from swing 1's high or low.
Swing 1 size so far at bar 24: from its start to its furthest point by the bar 24 close, in % ADR.
Day type: my own label for each finished day: Small Pullback Trend (one-way day with small pullbacks), Channel (one-way day with bigger pullbacks), Broad Channel (a slow, two-sided drift one way) or Trading Range (sideways). Trend day: my Small Pullback Trend or Channel label. The other way: opposite to swing 1. Broad Channel and Trading Range are their own lines.
Continuation / reversal: how far price goes after the bar 24 close, swing 1's way / the other way, by the close.
Swing Day Type: my sort of each day by what price does after swing 1. ORV: price goes back 1 tick past swing 1's start, then sideways. ORRVD: back past the start and on 1 swing 1 size the other way. ORRV²D: undone, then back past swing 1's end. TT: one swing all day. T: swing 1's measured move (one more swing 1 size) comes first. ORB: past swing 1's end, no measured move. TR: stays inside swing 1.
Middle day: the day in the middle when all days are sorted by size (half above, half below).
IN / PARTLY / OUT: on What holds, whether the data supports a statement fully, in part, or not.
Assumptions
A1. The leg walk on bars 1 to N (the app's Midday walk) is what a trader sees at the close of bar N.
A2. My Day Type labels as of 18 Nov 2026.
A3. Swing 1 has ended when price is 40% ADR back from its high or low.
Earlier work
Study
Where
Dates
Days
What matters here
First Swing Day Type
uubw/summaries/first-swing-day-type.md
2015-12 to 2026-10
2,725
Trend day the other way on 3.2% of ES days with a first swing (3.1% of all days): the baseline here.
ORRVD Study v2.3
UUBW v4/Open Type
2015-12 to 2026-11
2,748
Named these days "still running" on the whole-day rule.
Swing Day Type
uubw/summaries/swing-day-type.md
2015-12 to 2026-11
2,751
Sorts each day by what price does after swing 1 (TT, T, ORB, TR, ORV, ORRVD, ORRV²D); used in step 8.
Mixed bars with swing 1 not yet ended at bar 24: swing trend days 51% to 57%.
Kickoff
UUBW v4/Still Running Bar 24
2015-12 to 2026-11
2,757
Found the whole-day rule needs the rest of the day.
The steps
The question (this tab).
How we measure: the two rules drawn, and real days.
Other way by check bar: trend day the other way at every bar 6 to 48 (every 6th bar in the tables, every bar in the click boxes).
Swing 1 size at bar 24: which days with a first swing longer than 2 hours went the other way.
Day type by check bar: the trend day swing 1's way and Trading Range.
How far after bar 24: continuation and reversal from the bar 24 close.
When swing 1 ends: the bar its 40% ADR pullback lands.
Swing Day Type: where these days, and the days the other way, sit on my Swing Day Type.
ES RTH 5-minute, 2015-12-01 to 2026-11-17, 2,757 labelled days. FDAX Xetra 5-minute, 2021-08-03 to 2026-11-17, 1,351 labelled days.
Step 2 · How we measure
The question here: what does "first swing longer than 2 hours" mean at bar 24 itself? What each result would mean: if the two rules pick the same days, the post's count stands; if not, only the live rule can be used during the session.
Answer: They differ. The whole-day rule needs swing 1's high or low, and that is known only once price pulls back 40% ADR, often after bar 24.
Day A, drawn in % ADR from the open. At bar 24 there has been no 40% ADR pullback, so the live rule counts it as longer than 2 hours. Its high came at bar 20, so the whole-day rule does not.Day B, drawn. At bar 24 the walk has no swing yet. The whole-day rule counts it because a swing that started at bar 8 is confirmed later.
Real days with a first swing longer than 2 hours
ES 2026-11-09: bull swing 1 from bar 1, a bull Small Pullback Trend day. First swing longer than 2 hours on both rules. Prices from the app data.ES 2026-11-16: bear swing 1 from bar 1, a bear Small Pullback Trend day. First swing longer than 2 hours on both rules. Prices from the app data.
FDAX 2026-11-09: bull swing 1 from bar 1, a bull Small Pullback Trend day. First swing longer than 2 hours on both rules. Prices from the app data.FDAX 2026-10-19: bear swing 1 from bar 1, a bear Small Pullback Trend day. First swing longer than 2 hours on both rules. Prices from the app data.
What this step showed: the live rule counts Day A and not Day B; the whole-day rule does the opposite. Every step after this uses the live rule. Next: at which bar does the trend day the other way drop away?
Step 3 · Trend day the other way, by check bar
The question here: step 2 set the live rule; is bar 24 the right check point, or does the trend day the other way drop away at an earlier bar? What each result would mean: a sharp drop at one bar marks the check point; a smooth fall means no bar is special.
Answer: No single bar. The share falls smoothly on ES; FDAX bear swings hold near their baseline until about bar 21 (see the chart).
Baseline for this step: ES, RTH 08:30-15:15 Chicago, 5-minute bars, 2,757 labelled days. All days with a first swing: 2,666 (96.7% of all days), of which 85 (3.2%) became a trend day the other way. Bull and bear each have their own baseline below.
Bull swing 1
ES, bull swing 1: trend days the other way as a % of the days whose first swing has not ended at that check bar (day count under each bar). Dashed line: the baseline.
Check bar
Days
% of bull or bear first swings
% of all days
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Times the baseline
Broad Channel the other way
bar 6
345
25.5%
12.5%
12
3.5%
+1.3
1.57
10
bar 12
611
45.2%
22.2%
14
2.3%
+0.1
1.03
12
bar 18
685
50.7%
24.8%
11
1.6%
-0.6
0.72
6
bar 24
695
51.4%
25.2%
5
0.7%
-1.5
0.32
4
bar 30
688
50.9%
25.0%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.26
4
bar 36
651
48.2%
23.6%
3
0.5%
-1.8
0.21
2
bar 42
622
46.0%
22.6%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
bar 48
568
42.0%
20.6%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
Reference: whole-day rule (swing 1 high or low after bar 24)
653
48.3%
23.7%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
0
Baseline: all days with a bull first swing
1,351
100%
49.0%
30
2.2%
18
Bull swing 1: every check bar, 6 to 48
Check bar
Days
% of bull or bear first swings
% of all days
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Times the baseline
Broad Channel the other way
bar 6
345
25.5%
12.5%
12
3.5%
+1.3
1.57
10
bar 7
448
33.2%
16.2%
15
3.3%
+1.1
1.51
10
bar 8
494
36.6%
17.9%
11
2.2%
+0.0
1.00
12
bar 9
533
39.5%
19.3%
11
2.1%
-0.2
0.93
11
bar 10
580
42.9%
21.0%
13
2.2%
+0.0
1.01
12
bar 11
597
44.2%
21.7%
13
2.2%
-0.0
0.98
12
bar 12
611
45.2%
22.2%
14
2.3%
+0.1
1.03
12
bar 13
640
47.4%
23.2%
14
2.2%
-0.0
0.99
10
bar 14
650
48.1%
23.6%
14
2.2%
-0.1
0.97
8
bar 15
659
48.8%
23.9%
13
2.0%
-0.2
0.89
8
bar 16
670
49.6%
24.3%
12
1.8%
-0.4
0.81
7
bar 17
668
49.4%
24.2%
10
1.5%
-0.7
0.67
7
bar 18
685
50.7%
24.8%
11
1.6%
-0.6
0.72
6
bar 19
697
51.6%
25.3%
9
1.3%
-0.9
0.58
5
bar 20
706
52.3%
25.6%
8
1.1%
-1.1
0.51
4
bar 21
705
52.2%
25.6%
7
1.0%
-1.2
0.45
4
bar 22
704
52.1%
25.5%
7
1.0%
-1.2
0.45
4
bar 23
703
52.0%
25.5%
6
0.9%
-1.4
0.38
4
bar 24
695
51.4%
25.2%
5
0.7%
-1.5
0.32
4
bar 25
695
51.4%
25.2%
5
0.7%
-1.5
0.32
4
bar 26
693
51.3%
25.1%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.26
4
bar 27
697
51.6%
25.3%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.26
4
bar 28
693
51.3%
25.1%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.26
4
bar 29
693
51.3%
25.1%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.26
4
bar 30
688
50.9%
25.0%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.26
4
bar 31
686
50.8%
24.9%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.26
4
bar 32
678
50.2%
24.6%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.27
3
bar 33
673
49.8%
24.4%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.27
2
bar 34
664
49.1%
24.1%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.27
2
bar 35
660
48.9%
23.9%
4
0.6%
-1.6
0.27
2
bar 36
651
48.2%
23.6%
3
0.5%
-1.8
0.21
2
bar 37
646
47.8%
23.4%
2
0.3%
-1.9
0.14
2
bar 38
644
47.7%
23.4%
1
0.2%
-2.1
0.07
2
bar 39
634
46.9%
23.0%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
2
bar 40
626
46.3%
22.7%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
bar 41
627
46.4%
22.7%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
bar 42
622
46.0%
22.6%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
bar 43
616
45.6%
22.3%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
bar 44
610
45.2%
22.1%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
bar 45
603
44.6%
21.9%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
bar 46
582
43.1%
21.1%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
bar 47
575
42.6%
20.9%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
bar 48
568
42.0%
20.6%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
1
Reference: whole-day rule (swing 1 high or low after bar 24)
653
48.3%
23.7%
0
0.0%
-2.2
0.00
0
Baseline: all days with a bull first swing
1,351
100%
49.0%
30
2.2%
18
Bear swing 1
ES, bear swing 1: trend days the other way as a % of the days whose first swing has not ended at that check bar (day count under each bar). Dashed line: the baseline.
Check bar
Days
% of bull or bear first swings
% of all days
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Times the baseline
Broad Channel the other way
bar 6
388
29.5%
14.1%
23
5.9%
+1.7
1.42
23
bar 12
594
45.2%
21.5%
20
3.4%
-0.8
0.81
20
bar 18
607
46.2%
22.0%
13
2.1%
-2.0
0.51
9
bar 24
556
42.3%
20.2%
8
1.4%
-2.7
0.34
5
bar 30
499
37.9%
18.1%
6
1.2%
-3.0
0.29
5
bar 36
450
34.2%
16.3%
5
1.1%
-3.1
0.27
2
bar 42
395
30.0%
14.3%
1
0.3%
-3.9
0.06
0
bar 48
333
25.3%
12.1%
1
0.3%
-3.9
0.07
0
Reference: whole-day rule (swing 1 high or low after bar 24)
457
34.8%
16.6%
2
0.4%
-3.7
0.10
1
Baseline: all days with a bear first swing
1,315
100%
47.7%
55
4.2%
42
Bear swing 1: every check bar, 6 to 48
Check bar
Days
% of bull or bear first swings
% of all days
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Times the baseline
Broad Channel the other way
bar 6
388
29.5%
14.1%
23
5.9%
+1.7
1.42
23
bar 7
470
35.7%
17.0%
26
5.5%
+1.3
1.32
26
bar 8
526
40.0%
19.1%
26
4.9%
+0.8
1.18
26
bar 9
570
43.3%
20.7%
26
4.6%
+0.4
1.09
29
bar 10
583
44.3%
21.1%
25
4.3%
+0.1
1.03
25
bar 11
582
44.3%
21.1%
20
3.4%
-0.7
0.82
22
bar 12
594
45.2%
21.5%
20
3.4%
-0.8
0.81
20
bar 13
605
46.0%
21.9%
17
2.8%
-1.4
0.67
19
bar 14
602
45.8%
21.8%
16
2.7%
-1.5
0.64
15
bar 15
603
45.9%
21.9%
16
2.7%
-1.5
0.63
14
bar 16
613
46.6%
22.2%
14
2.3%
-1.9
0.55
14
bar 17
606
46.1%
22.0%
13
2.1%
-2.0
0.51
12
bar 18
607
46.2%
22.0%
13
2.1%
-2.0
0.51
9
bar 19
600
45.6%
21.8%
10
1.7%
-2.5
0.40
8
bar 20
589
44.8%
21.4%
9
1.5%
-2.7
0.37
7
bar 21
585
44.5%
21.2%
10
1.7%
-2.5
0.41
8
bar 22
574
43.7%
20.8%
9
1.6%
-2.6
0.37
6
bar 23
564
42.9%
20.5%
9
1.6%
-2.6
0.38
6
bar 24
556
42.3%
20.2%
8
1.4%
-2.7
0.34
5
bar 25
542
41.2%
19.7%
9
1.7%
-2.5
0.40
5
bar 26
540
41.1%
19.6%
9
1.7%
-2.5
0.40
5
bar 27
532
40.5%
19.3%
9
1.7%
-2.5
0.40
5
bar 28
517
39.3%
18.8%
8
1.5%
-2.6
0.37
5
bar 29
509
38.7%
18.5%
6
1.2%
-3.0
0.28
5
bar 30
499
37.9%
18.1%
6
1.2%
-3.0
0.29
5
bar 31
492
37.4%
17.8%
6
1.2%
-3.0
0.29
4
bar 32
486
37.0%
17.6%
5
1.0%
-3.2
0.25
3
bar 33
479
36.4%
17.4%
5
1.0%
-3.1
0.25
2
bar 34
466
35.4%
16.9%
5
1.1%
-3.1
0.26
2
bar 35
456
34.7%
16.5%
5
1.1%
-3.1
0.26
2
bar 36
450
34.2%
16.3%
5
1.1%
-3.1
0.27
2
bar 37
438
33.3%
15.9%
4
0.9%
-3.3
0.22
2
bar 38
432
32.9%
15.7%
2
0.5%
-3.7
0.11
2
bar 39
420
31.9%
15.2%
1
0.2%
-3.9
0.06
1
bar 40
415
31.6%
15.1%
1
0.2%
-3.9
0.06
1
bar 41
409
31.1%
14.8%
1
0.2%
-3.9
0.06
1
bar 42
395
30.0%
14.3%
1
0.3%
-3.9
0.06
0
bar 43
381
29.0%
13.8%
1
0.3%
-3.9
0.06
0
bar 44
371
28.2%
13.5%
1
0.3%
-3.9
0.06
0
bar 45
363
27.6%
13.2%
1
0.3%
-3.9
0.07
0
bar 46
350
26.6%
12.7%
1
0.3%
-3.9
0.07
0
bar 47
340
25.9%
12.3%
1
0.3%
-3.9
0.07
0
bar 48
333
25.3%
12.1%
1
0.3%
-3.9
0.07
0
Reference: whole-day rule (swing 1 high or low after bar 24)
457
34.8%
16.6%
2
0.4%
-3.7
0.10
1
Baseline: all days with a bear first swing
1,315
100%
47.7%
55
4.2%
42
Baseline for this step: FDAX, Xetra 09:00-17:30 Berlin, 5-minute bars, 1,351 labelled days. All days with a first swing: 1,328 (98.3% of all days), of which 36 (2.7%) became a trend day the other way. Bull and bear each have their own baseline below.
Bull swing 1
FDAX, bull swing 1: trend days the other way as a % of the days whose first swing has not ended at that check bar (day count under each bar). Dashed line: the baseline.
Check bar
Days
% of bull or bear first swings
% of all days
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Times the baseline
Broad Channel the other way
bar 6
174
25.8%
12.9%
7
4.0%
+1.7
1.70
5
bar 12
279
41.3%
20.7%
6
2.2%
-0.2
0.91
7
bar 18
344
51.0%
25.5%
4
1.2%
-1.2
0.49
8
bar 24
360
53.3%
26.6%
5
1.4%
-1.0
0.59
7
bar 30
352
52.1%
26.1%
4
1.1%
-1.2
0.48
5
bar 36
356
52.7%
26.4%
2
0.6%
-1.8
0.24
4
bar 42
336
49.8%
24.9%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.13
2
bar 48
325
48.1%
24.1%
0
0.0%
-2.4
0.00
2
Reference: whole-day rule (swing 1 high or low after bar 24)
366
54.2%
27.1%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.12
1
Baseline: all days with a bull first swing
675
100%
50.0%
16
2.4%
14
Bull swing 1: every check bar, 6 to 48
Check bar
Days
% of bull or bear first swings
% of all days
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Times the baseline
Broad Channel the other way
bar 6
174
25.8%
12.9%
7
4.0%
+1.7
1.70
5
bar 7
201
29.8%
14.9%
8
4.0%
+1.6
1.68
5
bar 8
228
33.8%
16.9%
9
3.9%
+1.6
1.67
6
bar 9
242
35.9%
17.9%
8
3.3%
+0.9
1.39
7
bar 10
258
38.2%
19.1%
8
3.1%
+0.7
1.31
8
bar 11
269
39.9%
19.9%
6
2.2%
-0.1
0.94
8
bar 12
279
41.3%
20.7%
6
2.2%
-0.2
0.91
7
bar 13
304
45.0%
22.5%
7
2.3%
-0.1
0.97
8
bar 14
322
47.7%
23.8%
8
2.5%
+0.1
1.05
8
bar 15
328
48.6%
24.3%
6
1.8%
-0.5
0.77
8
bar 16
336
49.8%
24.9%
6
1.8%
-0.6
0.75
8
bar 17
341
50.5%
25.2%
4
1.2%
-1.2
0.49
8
bar 18
344
51.0%
25.5%
4
1.2%
-1.2
0.49
8
bar 19
350
51.9%
25.9%
5
1.4%
-0.9
0.60
8
bar 20
356
52.7%
26.4%
5
1.4%
-1.0
0.59
7
bar 21
362
53.6%
26.8%
5
1.4%
-1.0
0.58
8
bar 22
361
53.5%
26.7%
5
1.4%
-1.0
0.58
7
bar 23
361
53.5%
26.7%
5
1.4%
-1.0
0.58
7
bar 24
360
53.3%
26.6%
5
1.4%
-1.0
0.59
7
bar 25
358
53.0%
26.5%
5
1.4%
-1.0
0.59
7
bar 26
358
53.0%
26.5%
4
1.1%
-1.3
0.47
7
bar 27
359
53.2%
26.6%
4
1.1%
-1.3
0.47
7
bar 28
357
52.9%
26.4%
4
1.1%
-1.2
0.47
6
bar 29
354
52.4%
26.2%
4
1.1%
-1.2
0.48
5
bar 30
352
52.1%
26.1%
4
1.1%
-1.2
0.48
5
bar 31
355
52.6%
26.3%
3
0.8%
-1.5
0.36
5
bar 32
359
53.2%
26.6%
3
0.8%
-1.5
0.35
5
bar 33
355
52.6%
26.3%
3
0.8%
-1.5
0.36
5
bar 34
354
52.4%
26.2%
2
0.6%
-1.8
0.24
4
bar 35
352
52.1%
26.1%
2
0.6%
-1.8
0.24
4
bar 36
356
52.7%
26.4%
2
0.6%
-1.8
0.24
4
bar 37
350
51.9%
25.9%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.12
3
bar 38
351
52.0%
26.0%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.12
3
bar 39
344
51.0%
25.5%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.12
3
bar 40
341
50.5%
25.2%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.12
3
bar 41
338
50.1%
25.0%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.12
2
bar 42
336
49.8%
24.9%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.13
2
bar 43
332
49.2%
24.6%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.13
2
bar 44
332
49.2%
24.6%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.13
2
bar 45
331
49.0%
24.5%
0
0.0%
-2.4
0.00
2
bar 46
330
48.9%
24.4%
0
0.0%
-2.4
0.00
2
bar 47
329
48.7%
24.4%
0
0.0%
-2.4
0.00
2
bar 48
325
48.1%
24.1%
0
0.0%
-2.4
0.00
2
Reference: whole-day rule (swing 1 high or low after bar 24)
366
54.2%
27.1%
1
0.3%
-2.1
0.12
1
Baseline: all days with a bull first swing
675
100%
50.0%
16
2.4%
14
Bear swing 1
FDAX, bear swing 1: trend days the other way as a % of the days whose first swing has not ended at that check bar (day count under each bar). Dashed line: the baseline.
Check bar
Days
% of bull or bear first swings
% of all days
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Times the baseline
Broad Channel the other way
bar 6
205
31.4%
15.2%
5
2.4%
-0.6
0.80
5
bar 12
285
43.6%
21.1%
9
3.2%
+0.1
1.03
5
bar 18
306
46.9%
22.6%
10
3.3%
+0.2
1.07
3
bar 24
302
46.2%
22.4%
5
1.7%
-1.4
0.54
1
bar 30
307
47.0%
22.7%
3
1.0%
-2.1
0.32
1
bar 36
285
43.6%
21.1%
2
0.7%
-2.4
0.23
1
bar 42
270
41.3%
20.0%
2
0.7%
-2.3
0.24
1
bar 48
257
39.4%
19.0%
1
0.4%
-2.7
0.13
1
Reference: whole-day rule (swing 1 high or low after bar 24)
289
44.3%
21.4%
1
0.3%
-2.7
0.11
0
Baseline: all days with a bear first swing
653
100%
48.3%
20
3.1%
11
Bear swing 1: every check bar, 6 to 48
Check bar
Days
% of bull or bear first swings
% of all days
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Times the baseline
Broad Channel the other way
bar 6
205
31.4%
15.2%
5
2.4%
-0.6
0.80
5
bar 7
230
35.2%
17.0%
4
1.7%
-1.3
0.57
6
bar 8
247
37.8%
18.3%
5
2.0%
-1.0
0.66
8
bar 9
259
39.7%
19.2%
8
3.1%
+0.0
1.01
6
bar 10
273
41.8%
20.2%
10
3.7%
+0.6
1.20
6
bar 11
275
42.1%
20.4%
8
2.9%
-0.2
0.95
5
bar 12
285
43.6%
21.1%
9
3.2%
+0.1
1.03
5
bar 13
297
45.5%
22.0%
9
3.0%
-0.0
0.99
4
bar 14
301
46.1%
22.3%
10
3.3%
+0.3
1.08
3
bar 15
300
45.9%
22.2%
9
3.0%
-0.1
0.98
4
bar 16
300
45.9%
22.2%
8
2.7%
-0.4
0.87
3
bar 17
303
46.4%
22.4%
10
3.3%
+0.2
1.08
3
bar 18
306
46.9%
22.6%
10
3.3%
+0.2
1.07
3
bar 19
302
46.2%
22.4%
10
3.3%
+0.2
1.08
1
bar 20
306
46.9%
22.6%
9
2.9%
-0.1
0.96
2
bar 21
310
47.5%
22.9%
8
2.6%
-0.5
0.84
2
bar 22
312
47.8%
23.1%
8
2.6%
-0.5
0.84
2
bar 23
307
47.0%
22.7%
5
1.6%
-1.4
0.53
1
bar 24
302
46.2%
22.4%
5
1.7%
-1.4
0.54
1
bar 25
307
47.0%
22.7%
5
1.6%
-1.4
0.53
1
bar 26
307
47.0%
22.7%
4
1.3%
-1.8
0.43
1
bar 27
305
46.7%
22.6%
3
1.0%
-2.1
0.32
1
bar 28
304
46.6%
22.5%
3
1.0%
-2.1
0.32
1
bar 29
304
46.6%
22.5%
3
1.0%
-2.1
0.32
1
bar 30
307
47.0%
22.7%
3
1.0%
-2.1
0.32
1
bar 31
307
47.0%
22.7%
4
1.3%
-1.8
0.43
1
bar 32
307
47.0%
22.7%
4
1.3%
-1.8
0.43
1
bar 33
303
46.4%
22.4%
2
0.7%
-2.4
0.22
1
bar 34
300
45.9%
22.2%
2
0.7%
-2.4
0.22
1
bar 35
292
44.7%
21.6%
2
0.7%
-2.4
0.22
1
bar 36
285
43.6%
21.1%
2
0.7%
-2.4
0.23
1
bar 37
281
43.0%
20.8%
2
0.7%
-2.4
0.23
1
bar 38
278
42.6%
20.6%
2
0.7%
-2.3
0.23
1
bar 39
274
42.0%
20.3%
2
0.7%
-2.3
0.24
1
bar 40
272
41.7%
20.1%
2
0.7%
-2.3
0.24
1
bar 41
274
42.0%
20.3%
2
0.7%
-2.3
0.24
1
bar 42
270
41.3%
20.0%
2
0.7%
-2.3
0.24
1
bar 43
267
40.9%
19.8%
1
0.4%
-2.7
0.12
1
bar 44
267
40.9%
19.8%
1
0.4%
-2.7
0.12
1
bar 45
268
41.0%
19.8%
1
0.4%
-2.7
0.12
1
bar 46
263
40.3%
19.5%
1
0.4%
-2.7
0.12
1
bar 47
261
40.0%
19.3%
1
0.4%
-2.7
0.13
1
bar 48
257
39.4%
19.0%
1
0.4%
-2.7
0.13
1
Reference: whole-day rule (swing 1 high or low after bar 24)
289
44.3%
21.4%
1
0.3%
-2.7
0.11
0
Baseline: all days with a bear first swing
653
100%
48.3%
20
3.1%
11
What this step showed: the later the check, the lower the trend day the other way, with no step change on ES; at bar 24 it is ES 1.0% and FDAX 1.5%, against 3.2% and 2.7% on all days with a first swing. The whole-day rule gives 2 ES days and 2 FDAX days. Next: what do the days that went the other way share?
Step 4 · Swing 1 size at bar 24
The question here: step 3 left 13 ES days and 10 FDAX days that went the other way. On the step 3 charts every one had a small swing 1. Does swing 1's size so far at bar 24 sort them? What each result would mean: if the days the other way sit only in the small sizes, size is a live read; if they spread across all sizes, it is not.
Answer: Yes. Every day the other way had a small swing 1 at bar 24, and the largest swings had none.
Baseline for this step: ES, RTH 08:30-15:15 Chicago, 5-minute bars. First swing longer than 2 hours: 1,251 days (45.4% of all days), 13 trend days the other way (1.0%).
Bull swing 1
ES, bull swing 1: each bar is the share of that size step's days that became a trend day the other way. Day count under each step. Greyed: under 30 days.
Swing 1 size so far at bar 24
Days
% of days with a first swing longer than 2 hours
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Trend day swing 1 way
Change, percentage points
Trading Range
100%+ ADR
38
5.5%
0
0.0%
-0.7
47.4%
+11.5
42.1%
80-100% ADR
95
13.7%
0
0.0%
-0.7
48.4%
+12.6
36.8%
70-80% ADR
82
11.8%
0
0.0%
-0.7
37.8%
+2.0
47.6%
60-70% ADR
119
17.1%
2
1.7%
+1.0
41.2%
+5.3
47.1%
50-60% ADR
183
26.3%
1
0.5%
-0.2
30.1%
-5.8
59.6%
40-50% ADR
178
25.6%
2
1.1%
+0.4
28.1%
-7.7
60.1%
Baseline: bull first swing longer than 2 hours
695
100%
5
0.7%
35.8%
52.1%
Swing 1 size so far is in % ADR.
Bear swing 1
ES, bear swing 1: each bar is the share of that size step's days that became a trend day the other way. Day count under each step. Greyed: under 30 days.
Swing 1 size so far at bar 24
Days
% of days with a first swing longer than 2 hours
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Trend day swing 1 way
Change, percentage points
Trading Range
100%+ ADR
64
11.5%
0
0.0%
-1.4
35.9%
+14.9
35.9%
80-100% ADR
79
14.2%
0
0.0%
-1.4
30.4%
+9.3
50.6%
70-80% ADR
66
11.9%
0
0.0%
-1.4
22.7%
+1.7
59.1%
60-70% ADR
90
16.2%
0
0.0%
-1.4
18.9%
-2.2
58.9%
50-60% ADR
131
23.6%
2
1.5%
+0.1
18.3%
-2.7
69.5%
40-50% ADR
126
22.7%
6
4.8%
+3.3
11.1%
-9.9
74.6%
Baseline: bear first swing longer than 2 hours
556
100%
8
1.4%
21.0%
61.2%
Swing 1 size so far is in % ADR.
Both sides together: swing 1 at 70% ADR or more by bar 24 on 424 days (33.9% of days with a first swing longer than 2 hours), with 0 trend days the other way. Under 70% ADR: 827 days, 13 the other way (1.6%).
Every case: the 13 days the other way
Date
Swing 1
Day type
Start bar
Bar swing 1 was confirmed
Bar of its high or low
Bar swing 1 ended
Size so far at bar 24 (ADR = 100)
Bar price went back past its start
Swing Day Type
2015-12-22
Bear
Bull Channel
1
10
10
38
43
38
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2016-07-21
Bull
Bear Channel
1
4
4
26
41
26
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2017-06-27
Bull
Bear Channel
3
11
19
38
62
44
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2018-12-17
Bull
Bear Channel
5
18
21
39
56
47
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2019-10-21
Bear
Bull Channel
2
8
8
37
41
39
Undone, then sideways (ORV)
2020-04-14
Bear
Bull Channel
11
21
23
52
47
53
Undone, then sideways (ORV)
2021-11-10
Bull
Bear Channel
1
5
11
36
67
44
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2022-03-31
Bull
Bear Channel
12
18
18
37
42
45
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2024-01-10
Bear
Bull Channel
3
8
8
38
41
38
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2024-02-15
Bear
Bull Channel
10
19
20
28
52
40
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2025-01-21
Bear
Bull Channel
4
9
9
29
45
30
Undone, then sideways (ORV)
2025-07-23
Bear
Bull Channel
1
6
7
29
47
29
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2025-11-10
Bear
Bull Channel
12
17
27
32
57
41
Undone, then sideways (ORV)
Sort:
ES 2015-12-22 · bear swing 1, 43% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelES 2016-07-21 · bull swing 1, 41% ADR at bar 24 · bear ChannelES 2017-06-27 · bull swing 1, 62% ADR at bar 24 · bear ChannelES 2018-12-17 · bull swing 1, 56% ADR at bar 24 · bear ChannelES 2019-10-21 · bear swing 1, 41% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelES 2020-04-14 · bear swing 1, 47% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelES 2021-11-10 · bull swing 1, 67% ADR at bar 24 · bear ChannelES 2022-03-31 · bull swing 1, 42% ADR at bar 24 · bear ChannelES 2024-01-10 · bear swing 1, 41% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelES 2024-02-15 · bear swing 1, 52% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelES 2025-01-21 · bear swing 1, 45% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelES 2025-07-23 · bear swing 1, 47% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelES 2025-11-10 · bear swing 1, 57% ADR at bar 24 · bull Channel
Dates to paste into the Browse tab
Baseline for this step: FDAX, Xetra 09:00-17:30 Berlin, 5-minute bars. First swing longer than 2 hours: 662 days (49.0% of all days), 10 trend days the other way (1.5%).
Bull swing 1
FDAX, bull swing 1: each bar is the share of that size step's days that became a trend day the other way. Day count under each step. Greyed: under 30 days.
Swing 1 size so far at bar 24
Days
% of days with a first swing longer than 2 hours
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Trend day swing 1 way
Change, percentage points
Trading Range
100%+ ADR
15
4.2%
0
0.0%
-1.4
20.0%
-3.9
60.0%
80-100% ADR
37
10.3%
0
0.0%
-1.4
37.8%
+13.9
37.8%
70-80% ADR
39
10.8%
0
0.0%
-1.4
33.3%
+9.4
51.3%
60-70% ADR
59
16.4%
0
0.0%
-1.4
22.0%
-1.9
66.1%
50-60% ADR
100
27.8%
2
2.0%
+0.6
19.0%
-4.9
65.0%
40-50% ADR
110
30.6%
3
2.7%
+1.3
21.8%
-2.1
60.9%
Baseline: bull first swing longer than 2 hours
360
100%
5
1.4%
23.9%
59.4%
Swing 1 size so far is in % ADR.
Bear swing 1
FDAX, bear swing 1: each bar is the share of that size step's days that became a trend day the other way. Day count under each step. Greyed: under 30 days.
Swing 1 size so far at bar 24
Days
% of days with a first swing longer than 2 hours
Trend days the other way
Chance
Change, percentage points
Trend day swing 1 way
Change, percentage points
Trading Range
100%+ ADR
17
5.6%
0
0.0%
-1.7
29.4%
+9.9
58.8%
80-100% ADR
35
11.6%
0
0.0%
-1.7
40.0%
+20.5
37.1%
70-80% ADR
44
14.6%
0
0.0%
-1.7
22.7%
+3.2
61.4%
60-70% ADR
68
22.5%
1
1.5%
-0.2
19.1%
-0.4
63.2%
50-60% ADR
59
19.5%
0
0.0%
-1.7
10.2%
-9.4
72.9%
40-50% ADR
79
26.2%
4
5.1%
+3.4
13.9%
-5.6
64.6%
Baseline: bear first swing longer than 2 hours
302
100%
5
1.7%
19.5%
61.9%
Swing 1 size so far is in % ADR.
Both sides together: swing 1 at 70% ADR or more by bar 24 on 187 days (28.2% of days with a first swing longer than 2 hours), with 0 trend days the other way. Under 70% ADR: 475 days, 10 the other way (2.1%).
Every case: the 10 days the other way
Date
Swing 1
Day type
Start bar
Bar swing 1 was confirmed
Bar of its high or low
Bar swing 1 ended
Size so far at bar 24 (ADR = 100)
Bar price went back past its start
Swing Day Type
2022-02-25
Bear
Bull Channel
1
9
15
26
61
32
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2022-05-31
Bull
Bear Channel
9
19
21
31
45
32
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2022-07-19
Bear
Bull Channel
2
9
9
27
48
29
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2023-07-28
Bear
Bull Channel
9
17
19
33
46
51
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2023-10-03
Bull
Bear Channel
7
13
16
34
59
51
Undone, then sideways (ORV)
2024-01-24
Bear
Bull Small Pullback Trend
4
10
10
33
45
38
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2024-04-23
Bear
Bull Channel
1
8
24
43
48
44
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2024-07-09
Bull
Bear Channel
5
9
26
45
59
53
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2025-03-11
Bull
Bear Channel
2
14
14
37
45
51
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
2025-07-31
Bull
Bear Channel
2
6
10
26
45
27
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
Sort:
FDAX 2022-02-25 · bear swing 1, 61% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelFDAX 2022-05-31 · bull swing 1, 45% ADR at bar 24 · bear ChannelFDAX 2022-07-19 · bear swing 1, 48% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelFDAX 2023-07-28 · bear swing 1, 46% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelFDAX 2023-10-03 · bull swing 1, 59% ADR at bar 24 · bear ChannelFDAX 2024-01-24 · bear swing 1, 45% ADR at bar 24 · bull Small Pullback TrendFDAX 2024-04-23 · bear swing 1, 48% ADR at bar 24 · bull ChannelFDAX 2024-07-09 · bull swing 1, 59% ADR at bar 24 · bear ChannelFDAX 2025-03-11 · bull swing 1, 45% ADR at bar 24 · bear ChannelFDAX 2025-07-31 · bull swing 1, 45% ADR at bar 24 · bear Channel
Dates to paste into the Browse tab
What this step showed: the trend day the other way sits in the smallest swings, 40% to 50% ADR at bar 24; from 70% ADR up there are none on either market, and the trend day swing 1's way rises with size. Next: how does the trend day swing 1's way rise as the check moves later?
Step 5 · Day type by check bar
The question here: steps 3 and 4 covered the trend day the other way; does the trend day swing 1's way rise, and Trading Range fall, as the check moves later? What each result would mean: a rise in the trend day swing 1's way makes a later check a stronger read; Trading Range staying top means the trend day is still not the most likely day.
Answer: Yes. The trend day swing 1's way rises with every bar and Trading Range falls; on ES bull swings they cross between bar 39 and bar 42; on ES bear and on FDAX they do not cross by bar 48.
Baseline for this step: ES, RTH 08:30-15:15 Chicago, 5-minute bars. All days with a bull first swing and all days with a bear first swing, each with its own day type mix (the shaded rows).
Bull swing 1
ES, bull swing 1: the trend day swing 1's way and the Trading Range day, as a % of the days whose first swing has not ended at that check bar. Dashed lines: the baselines.
Check bar
Days
Trend day swing 1 way
Change, percentage points
Broad Channel swing 1 way
Trading Range
Change, percentage points
Broad Channel the other way
Trend day the other way
bar 6
345
20.6%
-6.5
11.3%
61.7%
+1.9
2.9%
3.5%
bar 12
611
27.8%
+0.7
10.6%
57.3%
-2.5
2.0%
2.3%
bar 18
685
32.4%
+5.3
10.5%
54.6%
-5.2
0.9%
1.6%
bar 24
695
35.8%
+8.7
10.8%
52.1%
-7.7
0.6%
0.7%
bar 30
688
38.5%
+11.4
10.9%
49.4%
-10.4
0.6%
0.6%
bar 36
651
42.2%
+15.2
12.0%
45.0%
-14.8
0.3%
0.5%
bar 42
622
45.5%
+18.4
11.7%
42.6%
-17.2
0.2%
0.0%
bar 48
568
48.2%
+21.1
12.7%
38.9%
-20.9
0.2%
0.0%
Baseline: all bull first swings
1,351
27.1%
9.5%
59.8%
1.3%
2.2%
Each row adds to 100% across its five day type columns.
Bear swing 1
ES, bear swing 1: the trend day swing 1's way and the Trading Range day, as a % of the days whose first swing has not ended at that check bar. Dashed lines: the baselines.
Check bar
Days
Trend day swing 1 way
Change, percentage points
Broad Channel swing 1 way
Trading Range
Change, percentage points
Broad Channel the other way
Trend day the other way
bar 6
388
16.8%
+1.8
10.6%
60.8%
-5.9
5.9%
5.9%
bar 12
594
19.2%
+4.3
12.8%
61.3%
-5.4
3.4%
3.4%
bar 18
607
20.1%
+5.2
14.5%
61.8%
-4.9
1.5%
2.1%
bar 24
556
21.0%
+6.1
15.5%
61.2%
-5.5
0.9%
1.4%
bar 30
499
23.4%
+8.5
14.8%
59.5%
-7.2
1.0%
1.2%
bar 36
450
25.6%
+10.7
15.6%
57.3%
-9.4
0.4%
1.1%
bar 42
395
27.6%
+12.7
16.5%
55.7%
-11.0
0.0%
0.3%
bar 48
333
29.1%
+14.2
17.4%
53.2%
-13.5
0.0%
0.3%
Baseline: all bear first swings
1,315
14.9%
11.0%
66.7%
3.2%
4.2%
Each row adds to 100% across its five day type columns.
Baseline for this step: FDAX, Xetra 09:00-17:30 Berlin, 5-minute bars. All days with a bull first swing and all days with a bear first swing, each with its own day type mix (the shaded rows).
Bull swing 1
FDAX, bull swing 1: the trend day swing 1's way and the Trading Range day, as a % of the days whose first swing has not ended at that check bar. Dashed lines: the baselines.
Check bar
Days
Trend day swing 1 way
Change, percentage points
Broad Channel swing 1 way
Trading Range
Change, percentage points
Broad Channel the other way
Trend day the other way
bar 6
174
14.9%
-3.9
8.0%
70.1%
+4.8
2.9%
4.0%
bar 12
279
17.6%
-1.3
13.3%
64.5%
-0.8
2.5%
2.2%
bar 18
344
23.0%
+4.2
13.4%
60.2%
-5.2
2.3%
1.2%
bar 24
360
23.9%
+5.1
13.3%
59.4%
-5.9
1.9%
1.4%
bar 30
352
26.4%
+7.6
14.8%
56.2%
-9.1
1.4%
1.1%
bar 36
356
27.2%
+8.4
14.9%
56.2%
-9.2
1.1%
0.6%
bar 42
336
29.2%
+10.4
15.2%
54.8%
-10.6
0.6%
0.3%
bar 48
325
30.5%
+11.6
16.0%
52.9%
-12.4
0.6%
0.0%
Baseline: all bull first swings
675
18.8%
11.4%
65.3%
2.1%
2.4%
Each row adds to 100% across its five day type columns.
Bear swing 1
FDAX, bear swing 1: the trend day swing 1's way and the Trading Range day, as a % of the days whose first swing has not ended at that check bar. Dashed lines: the baselines.
Check bar
Days
Trend day swing 1 way
Change, percentage points
Broad Channel swing 1 way
Trading Range
Change, percentage points
Broad Channel the other way
Trend day the other way
bar 6
205
14.6%
+0.7
10.7%
69.8%
+1.6
2.4%
2.4%
bar 12
285
15.4%
+1.5
12.6%
67.0%
-1.1
1.8%
3.2%
bar 18
306
17.3%
+3.4
15.4%
63.1%
-5.1
1.0%
3.3%
bar 24
302
19.5%
+5.6
16.6%
61.9%
-6.2
0.3%
1.7%
bar 30
307
20.8%
+6.9
18.2%
59.6%
-8.5
0.3%
1.0%
bar 36
285
21.4%
+7.5
17.9%
59.6%
-8.5
0.4%
0.7%
bar 42
270
23.7%
+9.8
17.8%
57.4%
-10.7
0.4%
0.7%
bar 48
257
24.1%
+10.2
17.9%
57.2%
-10.9
0.4%
0.4%
Baseline: all bear first swings
653
13.9%
13.2%
68.1%
1.7%
3.1%
Each row adds to 100% across its five day type columns.
What this step showed: at bar 24 the trend day swing 1's way is above its baseline, but Trading Range is still the most likely day on both markets. Next: how far does price go after bar 24?
Step 6 · How far after bar 24
The question here: swing 1 is longer than 2 hours; how big does it get, and does price go further from the bar 24 close swing 1's way than back? What each result would mean: continuation well beyond reversal means room left swing 1's way; the two close together means the day still swings both ways.
Answer: No, only a little further. On the middle day continuation leads reversal by 2% to 7% ADR.
Baseline for this step: ES, RTH 08:30-15:15 Chicago, 5-minute bars. First swing longer than 2 hours: 1,251 days, bull 695, bear 556.
Bull swing 1
ES, bull first swing longer than 2 hours: its final size, one dot per day, smallest on the left.ES, bull swing 1: from the bar 24 close, the share of days that reach each distance swing 1's way (continuation) and the other way (reversal), by the close. Each side is a share of the same 695 days.
Distance from the bar 24 close
Continuation reached
Reversal reached
100% ADR
1.9%
5.3%
75% ADR
5.5%
11.7%
50% ADR
21.2%
23.6%
40% ADR
31.4%
31.4%
30% ADR
44.3%
39.9%
20% ADR
61.6%
53.1%
10% ADR
81.2%
74.4%
Middle day
27% ADR
22% ADR
695 days. Each column is read on its own: a day can reach both sides. Swing 1 final size: middle day 77% ADR, average 83% ADR. At the bar 24 close price sits a middle 50% ADR from swing 1's start.
Bear swing 1
ES, bear first swing longer than 2 hours: its final size, one dot per day, smallest on the left.ES, bear swing 1: from the bar 24 close, the share of days that reach each distance swing 1's way (continuation) and the other way (reversal), by the close. Each side is a share of the same 556 days.
Distance from the bar 24 close
Continuation reached
Reversal reached
100% ADR
8.8%
4.0%
75% ADR
17.6%
10.6%
50% ADR
33.1%
23.2%
40% ADR
41.7%
33.1%
30% ADR
54.3%
47.3%
20% ADR
66.9%
64.6%
10% ADR
81.8%
81.3%
Middle day
33% ADR
28% ADR
556 days. Each column is read on its own: a day can reach both sides. Swing 1 final size: middle day 79% ADR, average 89% ADR. At the bar 24 close price sits a middle 48% ADR from swing 1's start.
Baseline for this step: FDAX, Xetra 09:00-17:30 Berlin, 5-minute bars. First swing longer than 2 hours: 662 days, bull 360, bear 302.
Bull swing 1
FDAX, bull first swing longer than 2 hours: its final size, one dot per day, smallest on the left.FDAX, bull swing 1: from the bar 24 close, the share of days that reach each distance swing 1's way (continuation) and the other way (reversal), by the close. Each side is a share of the same 360 days.
Distance from the bar 24 close
Continuation reached
Reversal reached
100% ADR
3.9%
7.2%
75% ADR
11.1%
13.3%
50% ADR
29.7%
29.2%
40% ADR
39.2%
39.2%
30% ADR
54.7%
51.9%
20% ADR
70.6%
66.1%
10% ADR
80.8%
83.3%
Middle day
33% ADR
31% ADR
360 days. Each column is read on its own: a day can reach both sides. Swing 1 final size: middle day 74% ADR, average 83% ADR. At the bar 24 close price sits a middle 47% ADR from swing 1's start.
Bear swing 1
FDAX, bear first swing longer than 2 hours: its final size, one dot per day, smallest on the left.FDAX, bear swing 1: from the bar 24 close, the share of days that reach each distance swing 1's way (continuation) and the other way (reversal), by the close. Each side is a share of the same 302 days.
Distance from the bar 24 close
Continuation reached
Reversal reached
100% ADR
10.9%
2.6%
75% ADR
19.2%
10.3%
50% ADR
36.4%
27.2%
40% ADR
46.7%
35.1%
30% ADR
56.3%
51.3%
20% ADR
69.2%
66.9%
10% ADR
84.8%
84.4%
Middle day
37% ADR
30% ADR
302 days. Each column is read on its own: a day can reach both sides. Swing 1 final size: middle day 77% ADR, average 88% ADR. At the bar 24 close price sits a middle 48% ADR from swing 1's start.
What this step showed: swing 1 ends a middle 74% to 79% ADR from its start; after bar 24 continuation runs a little ahead of reversal on every side, by 2% to 7% ADR on the middle day; at 50% ADR and beyond, ES bull reversal is more common than continuation. Next: when does swing 1 end?
Step 7 · When swing 1 ends
The question here: step 6 measured how far; does swing 1 usually run on well past bar 24 before its 40% ADR pullback? What each result would mean: an early end means the read fades within the hour; a late or no end means it holds for the session.
Answer: Yes. Only 28% to 51% have ended by bar 48; 43% of ES bull swings never end before the close.
Baseline for this step: ES, RTH 08:30-15:15 Chicago, 5-minute bars. First swing longer than 2 hours: 1,251 days, bull 695, bear 556.
Bull swing 1
ES, bull first swing longer than 2 hours: running total of the days whose 40% ADR pullback has landed, by bar. The rest never ended before the close.
By bar
Days ended
Running total, % of the step's days
bar 30
61
8.8%
bar 36
130
18.7%
bar 42
181
26.0%
bar 48
231
33.2%
bar 60
300
43.2%
bar 72
346
49.8%
bar 81 (the close)
399
57.4%
Never ended before the close
296
42.6%
Bull first swing longer than 2 hours
695
100%
Price went back 1 tick past swing 1's start later in the day on 25.6% of these days.
Bear swing 1
ES, bear first swing longer than 2 hours: running total of the days whose 40% ADR pullback has landed, by bar. The rest never ended before the close.
By bar
Days ended
Running total, % of the step's days
bar 30
94
16.9%
bar 36
163
29.3%
bar 42
227
40.8%
bar 48
285
51.3%
bar 60
367
66.0%
bar 72
424
76.3%
bar 81 (the close)
458
82.4%
Never ended before the close
98
17.6%
Bear first swing longer than 2 hours
556
100%
Price went back 1 tick past swing 1's start later in the day on 27.5% of these days.
Baseline for this step: FDAX, Xetra 09:00-17:30 Berlin, 5-minute bars. First swing longer than 2 hours: 662 days, bull 360, bear 302.
Bull swing 1
FDAX, bull first swing longer than 2 hours: running total of the days whose 40% ADR pullback has landed, by bar. The rest never ended before the close.
By bar
Days ended
Running total, % of the step's days
bar 30
36
10.0%
bar 36
56
15.6%
bar 42
84
23.3%
bar 48
102
28.3%
bar 60
138
38.3%
bar 72
194
53.9%
bar 102 (the close)
275
76.4%
Never ended before the close
85
23.6%
Bull first swing longer than 2 hours
360
100%
Price went back 1 tick past swing 1's start later in the day on 31.9% of these days.
Bear swing 1
FDAX, bear first swing longer than 2 hours: running total of the days whose 40% ADR pullback has landed, by bar. The rest never ended before the close.
By bar
Days ended
Running total, % of the step's days
bar 30
26
8.6%
bar 36
59
19.5%
bar 42
85
28.1%
bar 48
104
34.4%
bar 60
146
48.3%
bar 72
195
64.6%
bar 102 (the close)
251
83.1%
Never ended before the close
51
16.9%
Bear first swing longer than 2 hours
302
100%
Price went back 1 tick past swing 1's start later in the day on 29.1% of these days.
What this step showed: the ends spread across the afternoon with no common bar; bull swings run to the close more often than bear swings on ES. Next: where do these days sit on my Swing Day Type, and where do the days the other way sit?
Step 8 · Swing Day Type
The question here: my Swing Day Type sorts every day by what price does after swing 1 (see my Swing Day Type study). Are the days the other way from step 4 trend days from the open, or opening reversals? What each result would mean: if they all sit in the undone groups (ORV, ORRVD), they are opening reversals that later trended; if not, they are a separate kind of day.
Answer: Yes, all of them are opening reversals. Every trend day the other way is an ORRVD or ORV day: swing 1 was later undone.
Baseline for this step: ES, RTH 08:30-15:15 Chicago, 5-minute bars. First swing longer than 2 hours: 1,251 days, bull 695, bear 556.
Bull swing 1
ES, bull swing 1: each Swing Day Type as a share of the days with a first swing longer than 2 hours. The coloured part is the days that became a trend day the other way.
Swing Day Type
Days
% of the side's days
% of all days
Trend day the other way
Trend day swing 1 way
Trading Range
One swing all day (TT)
296
42.6%
10.7%
0
67.6%
19.3%
Trading range (TR)
149
21.4%
5.4%
0
17.4%
71.8%
Undone, then sideways (ORV)
130
18.7%
4.7%
0
0.0%
97.7%
Opening range breakout (ORB)
61
8.8%
2.2%
0
36.1%
34.4%
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
35
5.0%
1.3%
5
0.0%
82.9%
Undone, back past swing 1 end (ORRV²D)
22
3.2%
0.8%
0
0.0%
90.9%
Trend (T)
2
0.3%
0.1%
0
50.0%
50.0%
Bull first swing longer than 2 hours
695
100%
25.2%
5
35.8%
52.1%
Bear swing 1
ES, bear swing 1: each Swing Day Type as a share of the days with a first swing longer than 2 hours. The coloured part is the days that became a trend day the other way.
Swing Day Type
Days
% of the side's days
% of all days
Trend day the other way
Trend day swing 1 way
Trading Range
Trading range (TR)
197
35.4%
7.1%
0
14.2%
67.5%
Undone, then sideways (ORV)
120
21.6%
4.4%
4
0.0%
94.2%
One swing all day (TT)
98
17.6%
3.6%
0
46.9%
34.7%
Opening range breakout (ORB)
88
15.8%
3.2%
0
42.0%
25.0%
Undone, back past swing 1 end (ORRV²D)
28
5.0%
1.0%
0
3.6%
89.3%
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
15
2.7%
0.5%
4
0.0%
60.0%
Trend (T)
10
1.8%
0.4%
0
50.0%
40.0%
Bear first swing longer than 2 hours
556
100%
20.2%
8
21.0%
61.2%
The 13 days the other way: 9 Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD), 4 Undone, then sideways (ORV).
Baseline for this step: FDAX, Xetra 09:00-17:30 Berlin, 5-minute bars. First swing longer than 2 hours: 662 days, bull 360, bear 302.
Bull swing 1
FDAX, bull swing 1: each Swing Day Type as a share of the days with a first swing longer than 2 hours. The coloured part is the days that became a trend day the other way.
Swing Day Type
Days
% of the side's days
% of all days
Trend day the other way
Trend day swing 1 way
Trading Range
Trading range (TR)
93
25.8%
6.9%
0
14.0%
68.8%
One swing all day (TT)
85
23.6%
6.3%
0
67.1%
14.1%
Undone, then sideways (ORV)
82
22.8%
6.1%
1
0.0%
97.6%
Opening range breakout (ORB)
54
15.0%
4.0%
0
25.9%
50.0%
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
24
6.7%
1.8%
4
0.0%
58.3%
Undone, back past swing 1 end (ORRV²D)
19
5.3%
1.4%
0
0.0%
84.2%
Trend (T)
3
0.8%
0.2%
0
66.7%
33.3%
Bull first swing longer than 2 hours
360
100%
26.6%
5
23.9%
59.4%
Bear swing 1
FDAX, bear swing 1: each Swing Day Type as a share of the days with a first swing longer than 2 hours. The coloured part is the days that became a trend day the other way.
Swing Day Type
Days
% of the side's days
% of all days
Trend day the other way
Trend day swing 1 way
Trading Range
Trading range (TR)
85
28.1%
6.3%
0
16.5%
69.4%
Opening range breakout (ORB)
65
21.5%
4.8%
0
30.8%
41.5%
Undone, then sideways (ORV)
62
20.5%
4.6%
0
0.0%
98.4%
One swing all day (TT)
51
16.9%
3.8%
0
45.1%
25.5%
Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD)
18
6.0%
1.3%
5
0.0%
72.2%
Undone, back past swing 1 end (ORRV²D)
14
4.6%
1.0%
0
0.0%
85.7%
Trend (T)
7
2.3%
0.5%
0
28.6%
28.6%
Bear first swing longer than 2 hours
302
100%
22.4%
5
19.5%
61.9%
The 10 days the other way: 9 Undone, reversal measured move (ORRVD), 1 Undone, then sideways (ORV).
What this step showed: a first swing longer than 2 hours that later turns into a trend day the other way is always an undone swing 1 (ORRVD on 18 of 23 days, ORV on 5). The other way comes only through an opening reversal, never as a trend from the open. Next: What holds.
What holds
ES
Finding
Tag
Baseline
With the condition
Change, percentage points
Step
Trend day the other way is low when swing 1 is longer than 2 hours
Answer: Once swing 1 has started in the first hour and is longer than 2 hours, a trend day the other way is low on ES and FDAX, about 1 day in 100, not 2 days in 11 years. When swing 1 has already run 70% ADR or more by bar 24, there were none. Every day the other way was an opening reversal (ORRVD or ORV), not a trend from the open. Trading Range is still the most likely day at bar 24, and after bar 24 price goes about as far back as on.
Live read
At the close of bar 24 (ES 10:30 Chicago, FDAX 11:00 Berlin)
If swing 1 started by bar 12 and has had no 40% ADR pullback, then a trend day the other way is low probability (ES 1.0%, FDAX 1.5%).
If swing 1 is also 70% ADR or more from its start, then a trend day the other way did not happen in the data (ES 424 days, FDAX 187 days).
If swing 1 is 40% to 50% ADR from its start, then the trend day the other way is still low probability but most of the cases sit here.
Either way, a Trading Range day is still about half or more likely (ES bull 52%, ES bear 61%), and the trend day swing 1's way is low probability (ES bull 36%, ES bear 21%).
From the bar 24 close, price reaches 30% ADR swing 1's way on 44% to 56% of days and 30% ADR back on 40% to 52%.
UUBW v4/Still Running Bar 24/data/*_StillRunning_PerDay_v1.0_20261120.csv
Checks
Known number: the whole-day rule gives ES 1,110 days and 2 trend days the other way, equal to the count in the blog post (recounted 20 Nov 2026) and to the app's own count; FDAX 655 and 2.
Second count: the app's own swing tables (bars 1-24 walk, one swing so far, swing 1 starting by bar 12) in SQL give ES 1,251 days and 13 the other way, FDAX 662 and 10, equal to this study.
Same swing: on every day with a first swing longer than 2 hours the bar 24 walk and the whole-day walk give swing 1 the same start bar.
Add-up: every day type mix row adds to 100%; bull plus bear equal both at every check bar.
Older half against newer half
Market
Half
Dates
Days
First swing longer than 2 hours
Trend days the other way
Chance
Baseline, days with a first swing
ES
Older half
2015-12-01 to 2021-05-21
1,378
612
6
1.0%
3.1%
ES
Newer half
2021-05-24 to 2026-11-17
1,379
639
7
1.1%
3.3%
FDAX
Older half
2021-08-03 to 2024-03-19
675
321
6
1.9%
3.3%
FDAX
Newer half
2024-03-20 to 2026-11-17
676
341
4
1.2%
2.1%
Follow-up
Swing 1 size at bar 24 as its own study. Step 4 found the 70% ADR line inside this study; it belongs to this question only. A study of its own would run the size at every check bar, ES then FDAX. Suggested: file it as an idea.
The blog post. Update the blog post's "Still running at 2 hours" section, its TL;DR line and its bar 24 line in "What I'm taking into the session" once this page is reviewed, with a dated Updated line and a link to the summary.
Side claims filed as ideas (20 Nov 2026): "Gap plus first swing" and "Bar 7 report days", in my Ideas list.
Version history
Version
Date
Changes
v1.1
20261120
The group "still running at bar 24" renamed "first swing longer than 2 hours". Title changed to match.
v1.0
20261120
First version. The whole-day rule from the post kept as a reference row; every step uses the live rule. Broad Channel the other way on its own line.