◆ Trading Research Story Report

First Swing Longer Than 2 Hours v1.1 · 20261120

When the first swing started in the first hour and is still going after 2 hours (bar 24), how often does the day become a trend day the other way, and what does the first swing do next?

Step 1 · The question

The question: my blog post "First Swing is Down: Is the Bull Trend Day Gone?" (zentradingtech.com) says: "If the first swing started in the first hour and is still running at bar 24, the trend day the other way is off the table. 2 days in nearly 11 years." Is that true at bar 24 itself, which bar is the right check point, and what does the first swing do next? This study tests a reading, not a trade setup.
Short answer: Low, not zero. At bar 24, 13 of 1,251 ES days (1.0%) became a trend day the other way. The "2 days" came from a rule that needs the rest of the day. No trend day the other way came when swing 1 had already run 70% ADR or more by bar 24.
Baseline · days with a first swing
3.2%
ES trend day the other way
First swing longer than 2 hours
1.0%
low 13 of 1,251 days
Change
-2.1
percentage points, from unrounded values
Times the baseline
0.33
relative change
How often
45.4%
of all ES days · about 114 a year

Key findings

  • A trend day the other way is low once swing 1 is longer than 2 hours. ES 1.0% and FDAX 1.5% of those days, about a third (ES) and a half (FDAX) of the share on all days with a first swing. Step 3
  • No single bar is the check point. On ES the share falls smoothly from bar 6 to bar 36; FDAX bear swings stay near their baseline until bar 21. Step 3
  • Swing 1's size by bar 24 sorts the days the other way. Every one of them had swing 1 under 70% ADR at bar 24. At 70% ADR or more: 424 ES days and 187 FDAX days, none the other way. Step 4
  • The trend day swing 1's way rises the longer swing 1 runs. ES bull: 28% at bar 12, 36% at bar 24, 48% at bar 48, against 27% on all bull first swings. It stays low probability (ES bull 36% at bar 24). Trading Range stays the most likely day until bar 39 to 42 on ES bull swings, and to bar 48 on the rest. Step 5
  • Every day the other way is an opening reversal. On my Swing Day Type all 13 ES and 10 FDAX days are ORRVD or ORV days: swing 1 was later undone. None is a trend from the open the other way. Step 8
  • After bar 24 price goes about as far one way as the other. ES bull middle day: 27% ADR on, 22% ADR back. Step 6
  • Swing 1 often runs to the close. On 43% of ES bull and 18% of ES bear days with a first swing longer than 2 hours its 40% ADR pullback never comes. Step 7

Terms

  • ADR: the average of the last 8 daily ranges, known before the open.
  • RTH: the regular day session. Xetra: the German day session for FDAX. Tick: the smallest price step.
  • Bar N: the Nth 5-minute bar of the session; bar 24 closes 2 hours after the open.
  • Leg: a move of at least 15% ADR. Swing: a move of at least 40% ADR built from legs, ended by a 40% ADR pullback. Leg walk: the rule that marks legs and swings bar by bar from the open; run on bars 1 to N it shows what was known at bar N.
  • Swing 1: the day's first swing. Its start bar is where it starts; its high or low is its furthest point.
  • First swing longer than 2 hours (the live rule): swing 1 started in the first hour (by bar 12) and has not ended at the 2-hour mark (the bar 24 close). At another check bar the same rule reads "not ended by that bar". The leg walk checks it: at the close of the check bar, the leg walk on bars 1 to that bar has swing 1 in, started by bar 12, with no 40% ADR pullback yet.
  • Whole-day rule: swing 1 starts by bar 12 and its high or low comes after bar 24, worked out on the whole day. The rule in the post; a reference row only.
  • Confirmed: the bar swing 1 first reaches 40% ADR from its start. Ended: the first bar price is 40% ADR back from swing 1's high or low.
  • Swing 1 size so far at bar 24: from its start to its furthest point by the bar 24 close, in % ADR.
  • Day type: my own label for each finished day: Small Pullback Trend (one-way day with small pullbacks), Channel (one-way day with bigger pullbacks), Broad Channel (a slow, two-sided drift one way) or Trading Range (sideways). Trend day: my Small Pullback Trend or Channel label. The other way: opposite to swing 1. Broad Channel and Trading Range are their own lines.
  • Continuation / reversal: how far price goes after the bar 24 close, swing 1's way / the other way, by the close.
  • Swing Day Type: my sort of each day by what price does after swing 1. ORV: price goes back 1 tick past swing 1's start, then sideways. ORRVD: back past the start and on 1 swing 1 size the other way. ORRV²D: undone, then back past swing 1's end. TT: one swing all day. T: swing 1's measured move (one more swing 1 size) comes first. ORB: past swing 1's end, no measured move. TR: stays inside swing 1.
  • Middle day: the day in the middle when all days are sorted by size (half above, half below).
  • IN / PARTLY / OUT: on What holds, whether the data supports a statement fully, in part, or not.

Assumptions

  1. A1. The leg walk on bars 1 to N (the app's Midday walk) is what a trader sees at the close of bar N.
  2. A2. My Day Type labels as of 18 Nov 2026.
  3. A3. Swing 1 has ended when price is 40% ADR back from its high or low.

Earlier work

StudyWhereDatesDaysWhat matters here
First Swing Day Typeuubw/summaries/first-swing-day-type.md2015-12 to 2026-102,725Trend day the other way on 3.2% of ES days with a first swing (3.1% of all days): the baseline here.
ORRVD Study v2.3UUBW v4/Open Type2015-12 to 2026-112,748Named these days "still running" on the whole-day rule.
Swing Day Typeuubw/summaries/swing-day-type.md2015-12 to 2026-112,751Sorts each day by what price does after swing 1 (TT, T, ORB, TR, ORV, ORRVD, ORRV²D); used in step 8.
Mixed 60min Opening Barsuubw/summaries/mixed-60min-opening-bars-day-type.md2015-12 to 2026-112,729Mixed bars with swing 1 not yet ended at bar 24: swing trend days 51% to 57%.
KickoffUUBW v4/Still Running Bar 242015-12 to 2026-112,757Found the whole-day rule needs the rest of the day.

The steps

  1. The question (this tab).
  2. How we measure: the two rules drawn, and real days.
  3. Other way by check bar: trend day the other way at every bar 6 to 48 (every 6th bar in the tables, every bar in the click boxes).
  4. Swing 1 size at bar 24: which days with a first swing longer than 2 hours went the other way.
  5. Day type by check bar: the trend day swing 1's way and Trading Range.
  6. How far after bar 24: continuation and reversal from the bar 24 close.
  7. When swing 1 ends: the bar its 40% ADR pullback lands.
  8. Swing Day Type: where these days, and the days the other way, sit on my Swing Day Type.
full size